Solid Timber Flooring vs Carpet

solid timber flooring vs carpet

Solid timber flooring and carpet each have pros and cons when deciding which is better for your home. When you take a closer look, it’s easier to see what is best for your individual needs.

What’s the Better Flooring Choice for Your Home?

Here are some important notes about choosing a surface in a room: Will the room need heavy traffic? Is there enough natural light in the room? Will it be frequently washed? What type of overall decor will you have in the room? These answers can help determine what kind of material may work best for you.

Difference Between Solid Timber Flooring and Carpet

Solid timber floors are a mainstay in homes throughout the world. It has been used for centuries and its beauty, durability and affordability make it an attractive choice. Timber floors add warmth and sophistication while making a room feel larger. The resale value of timber floors is much higher than that of carpet flooring.

The Disadvantage of Hardwood

A disadvantage to hardwood floors is that they increase dust mites and allergic reactions due to the fact that they can’t be completely sealed like carpeting can be. If you or someone in your home suffers from allergies or asthma this could be a deciding factor when choosing between carpet and hardwood flooring. After all, it’s better to be safe than sorry.

Natural Colour Hardwood

Another consideration with timber floors is their natural finish surfaces. These are not made to handle high amounts of humidity or moisture which are often found in bathrooms. If you are considering hardwood flooring for a bathroom, use sealed wood flooring options.

Carpet Advantage

Carpet is an integral part of many homes because it’s so easy to clean and can easily be tailored to fit your wants and needs. Carpet also has the ability to add colour, material or texture to any room, which may not always be possible with another flooring like hardwood floors or vinyl.

The Carpet Disadvantage

A disadvantage to carpet surfaces is that they tend to lose their elasticity over time and may become thin and flat, so it’s important if you have high traffic areas in your home that carpeting is chosen wisely. This can be overcome by having plush, thick carpets laid in these areas if necessary. Another protip, try to purchase carpets with a high wool content which may last much longer than other carpets.

The Cost of Each Material

Another factor to consider in the carpet vs hardwood floors battle is the cost of each. Having carpet flooring is usually cheaper upfront but may need to be replaced more often or have a shorter lifespan, whereas hardwood floors hold up for a longer time frame. Carpeting is also easier to install if you are going it alone, while hardwood floors require experience in order to ensure a good installation. In Australia, carpet flooring is usually around $30 per square metre, whereas hardwood can go $120 and above.

Carpet vs Solid Timber Flooring

When we look at carpet vs hardwood, each has its own benefits and downsides but the answer to this question depends on the usage of the room, the relative humidity in the air and who may be using it. Carpeting can increase allergies in some people because they are not good at resisting environmental challenges. Hardwood flooring is better for allergy sufferers but does require extensive maintenance while carpet does not.

There is no one size fits all solution when it comes to flooring choices so take into account what you prioritize most before making any decisions about which surface would work best for you. Installation and cost are usually per square metre ( or per square foot ) of flooring material.

Difference Between Carpet and Solid Timber Flooring

Unless you are in the business of selling flooring, it can be hard to imagine how something like carpet or hardwood flooring could have a significant impact on your life

A carpet is a covering that goes underfoot and shields your feet from cold tile or stone. It softens the noise of footsteps and cushions bony knees if you decide to sit on the floor one day. It absorbs sound and smells, which makes it ideal for rooms with babies sleeping nearby or pets sleeping elsewhere in the home. Carpet feels comfortable, often increasing humidity levels in a room where there is less ventilation than others, making it good for bathrooms and sewing rooms which get humid when people get ready for work or return from a run.

Carpet has downsides too, such as the fact that it collects dander and dust. If you or your family members suffer from allergies or asthma, avoid carpets or try to purchase a special kind that resists collecting dander and fabric softener sprays which make carpets easier to clean.

Hardwood floors offer a different set of sensations. Hardwood flooring is often lighter in colour than a given wall so they reflect light better making a room feel brighter. A hardwood floor is also easy to keep clean, swept regularly and can be mopped with any cleaner you use on your counters because there is no risk of damaging the finish. In wet weather outside, if you accidentally drop something that could damage your hardwood flooring, it may likely bounce instead of break. Hardwood flooring can be hard on the knees if you like to kneel or sit cross-legged on the floor regularly.

Solid timber floors are ideal for those who have time to refinish it or can afford to hire someone to do so once they become nicked and scratched from many years of foot traffic. Timber floors are susceptible to the elements and require regular care in order to resist damage from moisture and humidity levels that vary throughout the day. Hardwood flooring also won’t mask sounds like carpets but if you want something that enhances sound then hardwood may be your choice.

What is Carpet Made of?

Carpet is made up of many different materials, but the most common are nylon, polyester and wool. These fibres are woven together to produce the carpeting you see in your home.

A carpet flooring may feature various patterns or textures which can be used to enhance a particular room’s aesthetic appeal. Many times, carpeting is chosen based on what may provide warmth and comfort underfoot or help insulate against noise. Carpet cost is determined by a wide range of factors.

What is Solid Timber Flooring Made of?

Hardwood flooring is made up of material that has not been laminated or glues together like carpet. Instead, hardwood flooring planks are directly cut from a single piece of timber and then can be stained, painted or left at their natural colour. Hardwood flooring comes in the form of engineered, prefinished, parquet and hand-scraped options.

solid timber flooring vs carpet
Home Flooring Ideas

Engineered Floors

Engineered floors are only recommended for low traffic areas because they may not hold up as well against daily wear-and-tear like solid wood or prefinished options. Prefinished floors contain one coat of finish to help protect the planks during shipment and installation if you’re going it alone. Parquet floors feature various shapes to enhance your room’s design, while hand-scraped flooring is slightly more textured than solid wood floors to allow for better grip.

How is Solid Timber Flooring Installed?

Carpet is typically a much easier surface to lay down, oftentimes requiring no adhesive or nails. The material can be cut with a sharp knife or scissors and the edges can be hemmed in order to stop fraying. The downside about carpet surfaces is that they tend to need to be replaced due to wear and tear over time, especially if you have pets or high traffic areas of your home. In these cases, it may be beneficial to look into other alternatives such as solid timber flooring which tend to hold up well against daily use and last longer. Hardwood flooring tends to require an underlayment to provide insulation, comfort and noise absorbing properties. This is oftentimes made up of foam or cork depending on your budget.

Carpeting can be installed by a professional carpet layer or if you are feeling confident, you can lay down the surface yourself with an adhesive, nails or staples. If you choose to install the carpet yourself, make sure the flooring underneath is free from any debris to ensure a cohesive installation.

Hardwood flooring is typically installed in the same manner as carpets by nail or staple. The difference between installations is that they require a more delicate touch because of their sensitive material. If you’re looking to get solid timber flooring, then you may need to make sure the subfloor is free from debris and moisture before installation. Uneven surfaces can be levelled by adding additional layers of plywood or, in extreme cases, concrete. This process could only be done by a professional contractor if it’s required because it can be hazardous to your health if not properly contained.

What are the Benefits of Solid Timber Flooring?

After installation, both hardwood flooring and carpet require minimal care in order for them to look great year after year. Hardwood flooring tends to hold up better than carpet flooring when it comes to daily wear and tear, such as foot traffic, so they are often a better choice for active families.

Carpeting is also great at providing insulation and noise absorption which means it can be beneficial in colder climates where the sun doesn’t shine as often or noisy streets where you need to drown out the sound. A carpet can even be designed with extra soundproofing materials to absorb more outside noise.

Maintenance of Hardwood and Carpet

When it comes to routine care and maintenance, most solid wood flooring surfaces require a simple dust mop or vacuum. Carpeted areas may not always look as fresh because of daily foot traffic, but it is still important to make sure they are vacuumed frequently, especially high-traffic areas, in order to keep dirt from getting ground into an unhygienic mess.

A carpet can be made from materials that are stain-resistant, but it never hurts to place a blanket or rug at your front door for mud and spills. Hardwood flooring also comes in prefinished options if you don’t want to worry about staining down the line.

Hardwood vs Timber Flooring

There are many different types of flooring and hardwood and timber flooring are two of the most popular options. Hardwood is usually more expensive than timber flooring, but it can last a lifetime and has a rich, natural beauty.

Timber flooring is usually less expensive than hardwood floors, but it may need to be replaced more often because it can’t withstand heavy foot traffic or pets as well as hardwood floors. Between solid wood flooring and carpet really depends on the factors mentioned above as well as preference.

Oftentimes, homeowners opt for one flooring surface over another because it seems easier, but this isn’t usually true. Carpet flooring needs to be cleaned more often than hard surfaces like solid wood floors, but they also absorb noise which can be a crucial option if you have noisy neighbours. Solid wood floors are more costly than carpet, but it is easier to maintain and can withstand heavy foot traffic without wearing down too quickly.

Depending on the factors mentioned above, homeowners may opt for either flooring over the other and it comes down to your personal preference of what you think looks better as well as your daily routine of cleaning and maintenance.

Carpet or Hardwood Flooring, the Final Verdict

After carefully weighing the pros and cons of both hardwood flooring and carpet, it is your choice to choose the one that best suits your lifestyle. Do you have high traffic in your home or pets? Then maybe hardwood isn’t for you. But if spills are never a worry and noise insulation is important, then perhaps carpet flooring might be better suited for you.

Both hardwood flooring and carpets can be beneficial when it comes to noise absorption, insulation and daily wear-and-tear, however, it really depends on what you prefer in the end. Before installation of either, ask for the price per square metre, or per square foot, whichever style you prefer.

Related Flooring Resources

Flooring Quotes

If you’ve been looking for new flooring for a while and have recently been bombarded with sales pitches, you may be perplexed. When flooring companies start promising you the benefits of floating floors, it’s only natural that you’re doubtful. Here at Specifier, you can make an educated decision.


Floorer Call Out Fee

You know you need new flooring, but you don’t know how much it may cost. The good news is that regardless of your budget, there are lots of beautiful, long-lasting flooring options available to you. Read about it…


Hydronic Heating Cost

Hydronic heating is increasingly popular in Australia as the running expenses are up to 40% lower than ducted heating or underfloor heating. Read more…


Underfloor Hydronic Heating Prices

Because hydronic heating systems operate on water, they are more energy-efficient than other types of heaters. Read more…